Monday, March 30, 2015
LAST THURSDAY'S "DOC ZONE"
Well I've been receiving more phone calls than usual including from old colleagues and acquaintances. Apparently they all enjoyed the documentary. Even my kids who were born long after the American War on Vietnam, expressed surprise regarding Canada's political and economic ties to the war. Others while vaguely aware of Canada producing arms and ammunition were quite surprised with the linkage to either herbicides or chemical warfare depending on your point of view. In hindsight an argument could be made contrary to the rationalization at the time that herbicides solely targeted vegetation.
The Vietnam War became intensely unpopular in the United States. In fact like most wars it was the political ideology of the politicians in power that drove it forward. That said it was the young generation and their immediate families who paid the awful price.
Elmira, Ontario is not intrinsically a hotbed of pro war fanaticism. It may well have seemed at the time a logical extension for a company producing insecticides (DDT) and herbicides (2,4-D & 2,4,5-T) to supply Agent Orange as a herbicide to the U.S. military to defoliate jungles. The fact that Agent Orange had already been used for the purpose of destroying an enemy's food supply was not well known. Nor were the awful contaminants in it that produced terrible birth defects in human beings. Not well known by the public but still known by scientists and senior politicians.
The issue now is what are we doing about it now? Both for human beings generations later both in Vietnam and the U.S. as well as what are we doing here in Elmira. The answer in Elmira is that our political leaders are continuing the legacy of denial, deflection and distraction. As we speak friends and fellow travellors right here in Elmira are trying to defuse the discoveries of the last year approximately. Dioxins the toxic component of Agent Orange are still flowing down the Canagagigue Creek from Chemtura and eventually into the Grand River. Intentional bypasses of Uniroyal's toxic wastes have been discovered. A professional hydrogeologist has determined the high probability of Uniroyal's toxins flowing both east and south off site. The Ministry of the Environment quickly discovered even yet higher concentrations of DDT downstream in the Canagagigue in 2012 and 2013. Now they've decided to sit on the 2014 results while claiming lab delays. This is the politicans once more usurping authority from scientists and honest citizens.
Saturday, March 28, 2015
MORE ON WEST MONTROSE WATER
Well first off I have received an e-mail from Dan Kennalley of Woolwich Township advising me of the timing and availablity of the Staff Report being presented to Woolwich Council on April 14/15. If I were to have a bias towards Dan it would be a positive one due to regularily reading his Ontario Federation of Anglers & Hunters stories in their monthly magazine. Also he shares a fishing passion with my good friend Richard Clausi. This is the Staff Report dealing with the West Montrose water supply.
I have read the 2014 Region of Waterloo Annual Drinking Water Report for West Montrose. On its' own it appears substantially better than the 2013 Report. The Woolwich chlorine and microbiological Table on page 98 & 99 in the March 24/15 Council Minutes shows zero non-compliance in the West Montrose Distribution system for both 2013 and 2014. Then on page 101 in these same Minutes we have a somewhat different Table presumably produced by the Region of Waterloo indicating a reduction from 12 occurrences of non-compliance in the West Montrose Distribution System in 2013, reduced to two incidents of non-compliance in 2014. How can this be you ask yourself? Whatever the reasoning the Regional Annual Drinking Water Reports are designed by the Ministry of Environment (M.O.E.) to understate issues and indeed hide many while the municipal Reports are even worse. Part of the issue would include the fact that Woolwich are more concerned with the end of the Distribution System and the Region more concerned with both the beginning of the System as well as the raw water.
Taken as a whole and looking at the last eleven years of drinking water in West Montrose I am surprised that there haven't been outbreaks of E.Coli poisoning. Certainly the Boil Water Advisorys in 2004, 2005 and 2008 speak to a water system in crisis. The Region and M.O.E.'s claims of quantity problems only not quality problems in West Montrose are blatant lies. There is a very thick report produced by AECOM Canada Ltd. in January 2013 which is much more forthcoming. It is titled "West Montrose Water Supply Class Environmental Assessment: Project File Report" and is on-line.
The other mitigating factor is the Region bringing in water tankers for years, allegedly to solve water quantity problems alone. In fact this water is helping to dilute both the bacterial problems and the excesses of by-products of disinfection such as THMs, Chloramines, NDMA and Haloacetic Acids. The chloramines measured by the way I believe are monochloramine alone not dichloramine and trichloramine which are also health issues. Despite these tanker loads of water from outside the community, the residents of West Montrose have been and are still being exposed to dangerous levels of carcinogenic chemicals. The lack of testing and reporting of NDMA alone is quite shocking. It's hardly as if the excuse of twenty-five years ago, that nobody had heard of NDMA, is going to fly now.
Friday, March 27, 2015
WEST MONTROSE WATER APPEARS LESS UNSAFE THAN A YEAR AGO
OMG is this the second day in a row I have to say something nice about Councillor Mark Bauman? The discription I received of the discussion at Woolwich Council last Tuesday indicates that Mark was the only Councillor who asked questions about the Drinking Water Engineering Report. I was advised that Mark specifically asked questions about West Montrose water. While I'm on a Councillor back patting jag, kudos to Councillor Merlihan. You campaigned on reducing financial waste municipally and by gosh you are doing your best in that regard.
There have been a couple of e-mails back and forth this week regarding drinking water quality in West Montrose. While their wells remain contaminated with E.Coli, shades of past Walkerton and present aboriginal third world conditions in northern Ontario, this year's report doesn't look as horrible as last year's and some previous to that. Nevertheless there is unsurprisingly still E.Coli detections in their raw water. As they are still on their own wells, downgradient of their septic systems, this is unlikely to change. What was supposed to change was a pipeline over to Conestogo to either use their water or water from St.Jacobs also via a pipeline. Apparently there is no urgency to improve West Montrose water as long as tanker trucks are diluting and reducing the use of their wells and as long as the media remain toothless on this subject.
Spring is here and April rains may yet cause the disaster that has been waiting in the wings for years. If not, cancer will probably do the job based upon the decades long, high THM (trihalomethanes) and Chloramines concentrations. Finally it would be nice if the Region of Waterloo would also test for the other toxic products of disinfection (NDMA, HAA). Keep in mind all drinking water standards are based upon the ridiculous assumption that each contaminant is found in isolation versus the real world reality of multiple contaminants simultaneously.
Thursday, March 26, 2015
I HAVE NOT GIVEN UP ON COUNCILLORS MERLIHAN, HAHN AND L.SHANTZ
I know, I know. Burned a thousand times over the last twenty-five years and still cautiously optimistic. Truth be told I've been a bigger sucker for female liars than males. Why is that? That said Mark Bauman continues to stickhandle around facts and the truth with incredible skill and finesse. Unlike former Mayor Cowan whom it took very little time to understand; Mark continues to throw bones to those who don't trust him. For example his fairly insistent belief that the Stroh farmlands on the east side of Chemtura are drained by tile; I felt at first was to undermine the possibilty that the steel pipe discharging into the top (north) end of the Stroh Drain came from a groundwater collection trench draining Chemtura's shallow east side groundwater. As of the public CPAC Working Session this past Monday I have a whole new understanding of the implications of the possibilty that there is a tile drain system, right beside Chemtura's east side toxic waste pits, on the Stroh property.
These implications were enunciated by professional hydrogeologist Peter Gray of MTE Consultants. And Mark did not seem discomfited by Peter's hydrogeologic interpretation. Peter has already indicated in writing his belief that groundwater flows radially from the topographical high that is most prominent by the former IR-2, RPE-1, 2 & 3 on Chemtura's northeast corner. Radially as in west, east, south and possibly even a little north. What Peter advised us on Monday was that any drainage of subsurface water (ie. groundwater) on the east side of the Chemtura/Stroh property line simply lowered the groundwater levels there hence increasing the "head" or water pressure via gravity from Chemtura's property towards Stroh's. Therefore while this "head" already existed, drainage tile as Mark suspects exists simply exacerbates this flow of contaminated groundwater eastwards from the Chemtura site. Holy crap Batman!
Therefore if drainage tile exist on the Stroh property it has increased contaminated groundwater flow eastwards. If it doesn't exist then the steel pipe discharging into the north end of the Stroh Drain is most likely coming from the Chemtura property possibly via a surrepticious groundwater collection system. Chemtura are buggered BOTH ways!
One last huge revelation/confirmation from Monday's meeting. Chemtura senior management might want to put their affairs in order. They are still reading this Blog on a regular basis and they won't like this. As I suspected as an amateur hydrogeologist based upon twenty-five years of reading and studying hydrogeological reports from dozens of contaminated sites; the Stroh Drain is not only draining overland flow (surface water) and groundwater via the steel pipe (Stroh's and or Chemtura's) but it also will have a capture zone of nearby groundwater. Nearby groundwater such as the former Chemtura wetland approximately twenty feet west of the Drain.
This Councillors Merlihan, Hahn and L.Shantz is where you must come in. Both Chemtura and the Ontario M.O.E. are desperate to escape from revelations of their gross negligence in permitting discharges and drainage off Chemtura's site, into the Stroh Drain and then downstream via the Canagagigue Creek into the Grand River. Chemtura and the M.O.E. will say and do anything to avoid many millions of dollars in cleanup costs and or a totally appropriate inquiry into the M.O.E.'s negligence.
Wednesday, March 25, 2015
LAST EVENING'S WOOLWICH COUNCIL MEETING
O.K. first off an admission. I'd been out to the Woolwich Township Building for a public meeting the previous night regarding the Chemtura Public Advisory Committee. Hence after I presented my Delegation to Council I bailed out. Now a friend from CPAC who attended last evening gave me a call later on advising me to do some digging deeper into the Agenda and Council package which I did. It turns out that Woolwich Staff expressed some concerns with drinking water quality in West Montrose and possibly Conestogo and or Maryhill. They have a right to be so concerned.
I also received a phone call this morning from a Woolwich citizen concerned with issues in both Breslau and Conestogo. Apparently last evening Council exercised their discretion by refusing a Delegation who had not pre-registered for last evening's meeting. My understanding is that usually Council are quite flexible on these matters but last night chose not to hear from this resident regarding concerns about the development plans (school) in Breslau.
Back to my Delegation. I gave everybody a brief rundown about tomorrow night's 9 pm. CBC "Doc Zone" television show. I warned them that their will be at least a brief few seconds of photos of children born with birth defects courtesy of Agent Orange, Uniroyal Chemical and other manufacturers. I also advised that I will be a small part of that Documentary.
I also gave a rundown on the subverted Delphi Technique which is a method of manipulating groups of mostly uninformed people in order to come to predetermined outcomes. This is the primary purpose of Mayor Shantz's alleged "stakeholders" meeting scheduled for April 9, 2015.
Lastly getting back to the drinking water concerns in the Townships especially West Montrose. I presented documentation and concerns to Councillors Bauman and Bonnie Bryant a full year ago or more. Now suddenly Woolwich Staff are going to be presenting to Council in April their report dealing with my concerns and the Region of Waterloo and Ministry of Environment's responses a year later. I find this strange and sent off an e-mail this morning to Councillor Bauman and CAO David Brenneman asking if I was going to be informed about this ahead of time, or not.
Tuesday, March 24, 2015
MAYOR SHANTZ TAKE YOUR STUPID MEETING & SHOVE IT! CHEMTURA TAKE YOUR STUPID SOIL INVESTIGATION & SHOVE IT!
Well Councillor Bauman certainly undermined Mayor Shantz's position nicely last evening. Or did he? CPAC appropriately will not attend the Mayor's ingenious solution to a non existent problem ie. the "stakeholders" meeting. Sandy and Mark have both claimed that CPAC is the problem because Chemtura and the Ontario M.O.E. are boycotting public meetings. Last evening in a public meeting, Mark Bauman in front of both CPAC & SWAT advised that he is pushing the Mayor to permit all six CPAC members to attend AND to open the meeting to the public.
Until now Mayor Shantz had the public support of a five term Councillor who has been and still is a sitting CPAC member. That most likely will carry significant weight with the three new Councillors. Support that is for the meeting in the first place. That much is still to the shame of Mark Bauman. Apparently however he is smart enough to realize that making the meeting private and exclusionary is setting off alarms. The only reason Chemtura and the M.O.E. want this meeting is to set the stage, for not in the public interest reforms at CPAC. Councillor Bauman and Mayor Shantz are still on board with that.
Chemtura and their consultants, Conestoga Rovers, have a generally pathetic surficial soil sampling investigation plan for the east side of their property. Last evening CPAC's consultant, Peter Gray of MTE Consultants, further elaborated on his concerns with CRA's plan. It is my understanding that these concerns will be presented in detail at the April 30, public CPAC meeting. Some have already been elaborated here in prior postings.
Keep in mind that the above title is my attitude towards both the proposed meeting and the proposed soil investigation, not necessarily CPAC's or SWAT's. Both those groups while honest and informed, still have more patience than I or any other honest person having spent twenty-five non-stop years dealing with professional liars such as Chemtura and the Ministry of the Environment.
Monday, March 23, 2015
CHEMTURA ANNUAL MONITORING REPORT 2014
Well I'm just getting into this two volume annual report and already thre are problems. As usual the second volume (Appendices) is a shadow of its' former self. That said Appendix C while apparently still on a downward trend in number of wells tested and number of parameters tested for; still has a few shocks. The parameters mostly are NDMA, Chlorobenzene and Ammonia however there are a few wells with other ubiquitous Uniroyal/Chemtura chemicals in them. This would include petroleum hydrocarbons contrary to Jeff Merriman's claims as well as benzene in still surprising amounts. DDT is still present as are its' breakdown components.
NDMA has a few readings off-site in the 100 - 300 ppb range. That's right 100 - 300 parts per billion. The drinking water standard is .009 ppb so do the math and figure how many thousands of times higher than the drinking water standards NDMA still is in parts of the aquifer. Chlorobenzene has at least one off-site well with over 4,000 ppb. Coincidentally that's on the Yara (Nutrite) property where Wilf Ruland and Jaimie Connelly (M.O.E.) initially claimed there was free phase DNAPL only to later recant. Seems likely that they were right the first time around.
The Executive Summary at the start makes the statement that they are considering shutting down the E7 pumping well at the south end of Elmira. Well that's par for the course with this company and this corrupt Ministry of the Environment. I've sent the page to CPAC & SWAT and then on to Woolwich Council primarily the latter to remove plausible deniability. If those buggers are going to come to Chemtura's/M.O.E.'s rescue then they are not going to be able to say they didn't have adequate information on the neverending lies and scams of that pair.
Well E7 has pumped approximately 50% or more of the off-site pumping since 1998. Chemtura claimed in November 2012 that they were going to triple the off-site pumping in order to meet the 2028 cleanup deadline. Those f...ing liars have increased W5A/B and W3 while decreasing pumping at W4 and now they want to shut down E7. What a joke their credibility is. What a joke their "cleanup" is.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)