Thursday, November 19, 2026

YET ANOTHER PRIVATE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT HERE IN ELMIRA

 

There are different ways and different types of environmental assessments. There are Risk Assessments, Phase One and Phase Two Environmental Assessments. There was a Risk Assessment done ten years ago on the Varnicolor Chemical site on Union St. which indicated that the top two or so subsurface units were actually, after decades of remediation, quite clean. Below them however there were six chlorinated solvents from misuse and dumping that had penetrated downwards into the Municipal Upper and Municipal Lower Aquifers which used to supply our drinking water. That revelation basically is a glaring red light shining upon the negligence, incompetence and corruptness of the then Ministry of Environment (M.O.E.) now known as the MECP.  Literally for the previous 26 years the Ontario Min. of Environment had publicly claimed that Varnicolor's contamination was only shallow and that Uniroyal Chemical was the sole polluter of solvents, NDMA and chlorobenzene in Elmira's deeper, drinking water aquifers. Eventually all parties agreed that Nutrite (Yara) had also contributed ammonia to the mix although that took a full decade to become  public.

Two years previous to the 2016 Varnicolor Risk Assessment I had discovered and publicized the existence of the Stroh Drain which was built in 1983 parallel to Uniroyal Chemical's east side property border with the Stroh farm. This manmade Drain was only five to ten metres away from Uniroyal for a distance of about 125 metres and it connected into a tiny creek on the Stroh property that ran southwards both into and by the Martin swimming pond and then discharged into the Canagagigue Creek. The Stroh Drain collected both contaminated groundwater as well as contaminated surface water although it's main purpose was to drain the chemical swamp located across both the Uniroyal and Stroh properties. Prior to the building of the Drain the lowest land surface was on the Stroh property without a proper outlet and this "swamp" consisted of backed up groundwater, surface water and liquid chemical wastes both overflowing and leaching through the bottoms of the just north, east side waste pits and ponds. 

The so called "investigation" of the soils and groundwater on the Stroh property was of a quality and level of competence on a par with a bought and paid for, client driven consulting company intent on protecting the financial interests of their grossly polluting client. In other words it was essentially less than pathetic, less than complete, less than spurious and more than adequate to earn the consultants another MACHO Award or Memorial Award for Creative HydrOgeology. This coverup was done in order to not only save Uniroyal's corporate successors millions of dollars in cleanup costs but to also protect the MECP's tattered reputation for negligence and incompetence. Finally by burying the contamination under an Elmira By-Pass roadway plus commercial development; property stakeholders on the east side would likely support the arrangement. 

Meanwhile yet again the Creek and downstream residents are the losers as they have been for many decades.  Today's K-W Record advises us that the Region of Waterloo with their tattered environmental reputation based upon the Wilmot Land Grab and the recent and ongoing Regional Water Crisis are having an Open House in the first week of December to review the findings for the preferred route of the by-pass on the east side. Most of their Open Houses are strictly controlled dog and pony shows not allowing full, honest and open public discussion. That avoids difficult and embarrassing revelations by informed members of the public. It is preferred by politicians and other dishonest brokers.  

;

No comments:

Post a Comment