Tuesday, March 17, 2015

CPAC'S "MANUFACTURED CRISIS" MAKES THE K-W RECORD



First off the Waterloo Region Record owes CPAC an apology. The staff reporter who wrote the article in today's Record titled ""Dysfunction" on Elmira committee" should have interviewed CPAC's Chair, Dr. Dan Holt. Indeed she contacted him twice over a week ago and my understanding is that he was ready, able and willing to speak to her. She mangaged to procrastinate long enough that he finally was gone for holidays last weekend and part of this week. Then she speaks to a know nothing Ministry of the Environment "spokesperson" and to Councillor Mark Bauman. Mark does NOT speak on behalf of CPAC. If he speaks for anyone other than himself it is for Woolwich Council and in my opinion sometimes Chemtura's interests.

That said Mark could have done incredible damage to the truth with inaccurate comments. Overall I believe that short of his comments about inappropriate personal attacks he actually wasn't as bad as I feared from the way the article started out. Mark appears to be calling for a third party review of the method of the investigation and results. The devil of course is in the details. When the smoke clears lets hear what his position is then.

I will also moderate my criticism of reporter Paige Desmond in that she did point out that the 2028 deadline to cleanup Elmira's Aquifers is not on track. She also referenced a professional report (MTE Consultants) that there was a high potential for contamination to have spread south and east of the Chemtura property. Finally she also referenced the October 7, 1991 Settlement Agreement aka "Sweetheart Deal" between Chemtura and the Ont. M.O.E.. Hmm, I'm wondering something here. Did she get that info from e-mails she's received, from Mark Bauman (unlikely) or did she at the last minute talk to Dr. Dan Holt and simply not mention it here in her article? Very strange.

Reporter Paige Desmond refers to a CPAC membership shakeup. Mayor Shantz, Chemtura and the M.O.E. want to defang CPAC in a manner that doesn't appear authoritarian or dictatorial. The alleged "stakeholders" meeting is part of that plan. Unfortunately for the Mayor her political skills of manipulation, while subtle, have been unsucessful in fooling CPAC into compliance. They have politely said no thanks to her entreaties that originally one, now two members attend. CPAC are holding out for six members (all) attending plus it be a public meeting. Even with six members they will be grossly outnumbered at the table.

Part of the Mayor's plan has been to tarnish CPAC with my blunt disapproval of Chemtura, the M.O.E. and their fellow travellors on Woolwich Council. I have repeatedly over the last few months both verbally and in writing made it clear that I do not speak on behalf of CPAC. While I was a member of the sub-committee of CPAC called SWAT (soil, water, air & technical) from approximately 2012 through 2014 I determined that my aggressive defence of CPAC and SWAT here, at Council meetings as a Delegate and via e-mails would be used by dishonest persons as an opening to tarnish CPAC and SWAT. Therefore weeks and months ago I offerred my resignation in writing to Dr. Dan. This written resignation is signed and dated by yours truly. Both CPAC and SWAT members (less 1) know this which is exactly why they have not felt compelled to respond to stupid references that they are somehow responsible for my words. That said we are indeed friends and colleagues and that will not change.

As CPAC appointed persons to SWAT without any input from Council, they certainly don't need any input from or notice to them regarding changes in SWAT membership. There are actually several SWAT members that Council are unaware of. Council and Mark Bauman, should have read more carefully how I signed my Delegations to Council. They should have paid attention when I told them point blank that I did not represent CPAC. They should have noticed that I did not have my name on last week's Letter To The Editor signed by CPAC members and two SWAT members. Perhaps they've been too darn busy looking for minor openings with which to attack CPAC.

Monday, March 16, 2015

TELL THE TRUTH SANDY



Look if Mayor Shantz and a colleague or two on the new Woolwich Council want to rescue Chemtura, save their reputation and several millions of dollars; feel free, go ahead. If Chemtura are privately threatening to leave Elmira without Woolwich Township intervention to hobble the current Chemtura Public Advisory Committee, again fine , so be it. But what you must stop doing Mayor Sandy Shantz is lying to CPAC and the public. If you want to crush, weaken, water down, threaten or intimidate CPAC into submission you will do so honestly and openly. No more lies!

For those of us in the know locally, your agenda has become blatant. Chemtura and the Ministry of Environment have manufactured a crisis by boycotting the last three public CPAC meetings. They have done this on your watch with your blessing. Your response has been to promote a private, secret discussion between pretend stakeholders. Any real discussion and meeting on the 2028 cleanup deadline for the Elmira Aquifers and on the ongoing discharges of Dioxins (2,3,7,8 TCDD)and DDT off the east side of Chemtura and then down the Canagagigue Creek must include six CPAC members and be public.

You have appointed two local residents to your pretend stakeholders meeting who have the appearance of a conflict of interest. It is most likely that they are the very same pair who along with the current CPAC members reapplied for appointment last Novemeber. To date you have refused to admit that. I have sent you and the rest of Council further evidence this weekend indicating that one of them has worked with, "assisted", or collaborated with Chemtura's long time consultants Conestoga Rovers (CRA) on their E:DAT project (3-D groundwater modelling). This evidence includes at least half a dozen honest witnesses to that specific conversation between Steve Quigley of CRA and Susan Bryant at the November 29, 2012 public CPAC meeting. Other evidence includes hand written notes from that meeting plus a formal posting here and publicly available on the Elmira Advocate since the next morning ie. November 30/12. Lastly all public CPAC meetings are recorded. This public conversation was recorded and with the date and time available can easily be checked. These recordings however are solely under the control of Woolwich Township. Rest assurred Mayor Sandy and her CAO will never voluntarily release them and substantiate that those who deny this conversation regarding collaboration, are lying.

The second plant on this pretend stakeholders meeting is past Woolwich Councillor Pat McLean. She has been jetting across North America on the Chemical Industry's dime for at least a decade including secretly while the Chair of a citizens public advisory committee (CPAC). She was appointed to the National Advisory Panel of the Chemical Industry Association of Canada (CIAC). Her technical, chemical and scientific skills are literally nil. This appointment was due to her Chairmanship of CPAC plus most likely a recommendation from Chemtura. Her "secret" membership plus perks came to light via the Internet. Her name and photograph indicate different venues and meetings across the continent she has attended on an all expenses paid basis. I was a voting CPAC member from 2000 until 2008 and never was I told or informed as to what she was doing on behalf of the chemical industry.

Woolwich Council no longer have plausible deniability. They have been informed and must do the right thing. That means, that pair, off of both the "stakeholders" meeting where they allegedly are representing the public interest and they must not be appointed to the incoming CPAC for the same reason. Anything less and Woolwich council are complicit in this fraud being perpetrated upon the public. I repeat Sandy you can have your way but you will tell the public exactly the truth and what you are doing. The deception must stop.

Saturday, March 14, 2015

FURTHER DETAILS ON DR. DAN HOLT'S LETTER TO THE EDITOR



I posted two days ago about the CPAC Chair's Letter To The Editor that was published last Thursday in the Elmira Independent. Here are some specifics.

CPAC has been functioning extremely well for the last four years contrary to the Mayor's assertion otherwise . This is specifically why Chemtura and the Ontario M.O.E. are running for cover beneath the Woolwich Township umbrella. Those two parties want and expect a tame, pretend public consultation at which they can present their glossy version without serious questions or criticisms.

The current major issue is the east side discharge of Dioxins and DDT into the natural environment via the Stroh property and Drain. The 2028 non-cleanup of the Elmira Aquifers is another hugely serious problem.

Mayor Shantz's claims that her proposed private meeting and secret discussions are O.K. because it is a "Working Meeting" is just typical, political doublespeak and nonsense. As far as the meeting being sidetracked by being public and inclusive of all five CPAC members is further nonsense. Dr. Dan has indicated the professional credentials of the CPAC members. More likely it is Chemtura and the M.O.E. who will sidetrack things.

Mayor Shantz's nonsense about CPAC not participating in the process is simply both rude and woefully ignorant. They've been participating while she's been at home sitting on her butt for the last four years. Such bullshit Sandy!

The M.O.E. are the problem. They are comprimised and have long been working on behalf of the polluter rather than in the public interest. Blaming CPAC while allowing Chemtura and the M.O.E. a six month respite from answering hard questions about the east side of their property is disgraceful. It is in my learned opinion that this is typical of Woolwich Township's behaviour over most of the last twenty-five years.

Friday, March 13, 2015

THE ENVIRONMENTAL DEMISE OF PAT & SUSAN



Last Saturday I posted here that I had sent a two page Document to Woolwich Council and the media among others titled "Both the Appearance and Reality of a Conflict of Interest". That document was replied to and sent to the parties yesterday by Susan Bryant. I have already, paragraph by paragraph, commented on her confirmations of my data as well as two of her denials. Furthermore she has somewhat added to the fire by indicating meals (Swiss Chalet) being provided to various meetings. If nothing more this would indicate to me that Chemtura treat their supporters much more courteously and respectfully than their critics.

Susan also confirms a single plane trip for citizen volunteers to a CRA cleanup site. There are no details such as who specifically went (likely Pat Mclean), where the location was (likely U.S.) or how long the trip lasted. Interestingly it just crossed my wee mind that I believe Pat Mclean was a Woolwich Councillor at the time. Hmm could that be a double conflict of interest? You know Mayor Shantz and Councillor Bauman that your support for Pat & Susan is starting to blow up in your faces? Mark Bauman tried unsucessfully to get Susan put back on CPAC a year and a half ago. Meanwhile the Mayor has appointed both Pat & Susan to the phoney "stakeholders" meeting scheduled for April 9/15.

Currently Woolwich Township by association with former Mayor Cowan are in the news for his alleged breech of trust, fraud etc.. While I'm no lawyer my allegations have at most been about the appearance of Pat & Susan having a conflict of interest. I simply can't see how they can pretend to be solely motivated by the public interest versus their own when they have both personally benefited by their association with Chemtura Canada and the Chemtura Public Advisory Committee (CPAC).

Lastly today's Woolwich Observer carrys an article and photograph about Bob Burtt's book which came out last fall. This book was affectionately referred to as "The Saga of Susan" by my friend and colleague Dr. Henry Regier. That said not a single mention of Susan in the Observer's writeup this morning. Well, well, well. Interestingly part owner of the Observer is Councillor Patrick Merlihan. The title of today's Observer article is "Officials not safeguarding Elmira's groundwater, says author of new book".

Thursday, March 12, 2015

CPAC GOES PUBLIC



Today's Elmira Independent carrys this Letter To The Editor titled "Meeting with MOECC and Chemtura should be public". The letter is written and signed by Dr. Dan Holt, CPAC Chair. It was written on behalf of and with prior agreement to the contents by all six CPAC members and two SWAT team members. The other three SWAT team members are not as involved on a day to day basis as Dr. Henry Regier and Richard Clausi. Voting Chemtura Public Advisory Committee (CPAC) members consist of Dr. Dan, Sebastian Seibel-Achenbach, Vivienne Delaney, Ron Campbell, Graham Chevreau and Councillor Mark Bauman. Soil, Water, Air, Technical (SWAT) are a sub-committee of CPAC appointed by them hence going around certain Woolwich Council biases and personalities. Chemtura totally despise the acronym SWAT as it signifies to them an emergency situation. They and their pet regulator, the MOE, prefer to pretend that everything is under control.

Councillor Mark Bauman in my opinion is a world class SBS expert. This stands for sucking and blowing simultaneously. He and he alone could have and should have stood up to the new Mayor based upon his five terms on Council and his last three years as a CPAC member. I do not believe for one second that her immediate CPAC crisis promotion was not supported by Mark Bauman. Indeed at the start of the January CPAC meeting he spoke with her making asinine claims that CPAC's disrespectful behaviour was at the root of Chemtura's and the M.O.E.'s non appearance. That was a blatant lie. Yet here he is signing a Letter To The editor which essentially is condemning Mayor Shantz's earlier Elmira Independent interview. What a guy.

Dr. Dan speaks honestly and accurately and dispels many of the misconceptions and intentional misleading in Mayor Shantz's comments. The only reason to have this meeting in private is so that Chemtura and the Ministry of the Environment (M.O.E.) can do what they do best which is lie and preferably without getting caught publicly doing it.

Wednesday, March 11, 2015

A MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR OF CPAC



Following is the text of a statement given by Dr. Dan Holt, CPAC Chair, at the last public CPAC meeting on February 26, 2015. It is extraordinary for its' detailed and forthright explanation of both the environmental and political situation here in Elmira, Ontario regarding Chemtura Canada (formerly Uniroyal Chemical).

One note: The initial proposed suspension of further meetings was discussed and it was decided not to proceed with that.


"Since Chemtura and MOECC have not shown up for the February meeting I propose we have a motion to suspend all future meetings until May 2015 or until they are ready to act like grownups and return. They have shown disrespect for CPAC, Council, and the people of Elmira by their actions and lack of actions for the past several years. Respect is a two way street and being purposely deceptive and pretending to take actions to remediate the aquifer over the years when in fact they are not doing what would actually help is not respectful.

The Mayor has met with both Chemtura and the MOECC and not knowing what she has promised the MOECC and Chemtura they still have not shown up for meetings. It is apparent that they are not interested in truly working together. I propose that CPAC suspend all future meetings until Chemtura and the MOECC are ready to respect all parties involved and return ready to actually work toward a goal of real remediation of the aquifer.

Chemtura and the MOECC pretend that they are the victims in all of this. The Council and Mayor are being deceived based on their attendance at one or two CPAC meetings in four years. The real victims are the residents of Elmira who had their clean fresh water stolen by Chemtura over 30 years ago which in turn is costing the residents higher water bills.

Chemtura deceived this committee and the people of Elmira when they, for a year or more, declared that they would meet the 2028 deadline by their current methods and pumping rates while they had the data all along, that they would later reveal, which indicated that they would not reach the 2028 goal without increasing the pumping rates by 300%. And after two years they still have not increased the rates but in some cases reduced the pumping rates.

The MOECC is not living up to its responsibilities under the Environmental Protection Act (EPA). They have the authority and responsibility to go on property with or without permission to investigate contamination and possible hazards to human health, animal life, and the environment and they steadfastly refuse to carry out their duty. They are continuing to spend over $600,000/year that we know of, of taxpayer's money, without accomplishing a true claenup of the aquifer. Instead of supporting the efforts of CPAC, the representatives of the people, the MOECC consistently support the inaction of Chemtura.

Chemtura has a history of this type of avoidance of cleaning up their messes in other locations (Red Hook Park in Brooklyn for one) and that indicates to me that they are playing a game of delay and obfuscation at the expense of the residents. I personally have been publicly attacked and called a liar at a Council meeting when I had no way to defend my honour or myself. Of course, the Chemtura representative who defamed me in public later apologized in private and said he didn't want to do that, but the corporate higher ups forced him. Why is that nor part of this discussion of work place harassment? Steve Quigley has many times insulted this committee. George Karlos has insulted this committee. Josef Olejarz has been disrespectful. Why is all this blame heaped on CPAC (for the other two parties not showing up)?

We should entertain shutting down all of it and save the taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars per year. The aquifer is not going to be cleaned up under the current process...the MOECC won't even give us a definition of what "cleaned up according to the ODWS" means. It has now been over a year since we requested that definition from the MOECC. Eric Hodgins, of the Region, has told us that the aquifer will have to rest after the declaration of "clean" is made anyway so why not now?

I for one am tired of being taken for granted, disrespected and bullied. My time, effort, and talents are worrth a lot more than I'm getting for this endeavour. respect is a two way street, nothing is being accomplished, so let's shut it down.

If we don't do this then it is time to bring in the big guns from outside to spread the word via the media. Ron is right...the 1991 Settlement Agreement is the guiding factor in all this and that means that Council, the people and CPAC have no real chance to make any difference in this anyway. That deal was struck to protect Chemtura from ever having to really spend the money to clean up the aquifer and surrounding contamination. The MOECC will always protect Chemtura because they are afraid of more legal action.

I want to take this opportunity to express my appreciation and admiration for those who have fought this battle for the past 25 years. Too many to name and I don't even know them all, but I do know Henry, Rich and Alan. Thank you for having the determination, knowledge and willingness to put up with all the nonsense that has been thrown at you over the years. The residents don't even know what you've done for them and continue to do to right a wrong perpetrated on the population of Elmira and the environment we all share."


Tuesday, March 10, 2015

AWAITING THE INDEPENDENT & OBSERVER WRITEUPS



I am awaiting this week's Elmira Independent and Woolwich Observer's editions to come out on Thursday and Friday respectively. Both papers did not write up three Delegations which took place at last Tuesday's March 3 Committee of the Whole 6 pm. meeting. These Delegations were from Dr. Henry Regier, Lisa Macdonald and myself. Considering the significance of all three Delegations I would be quite surprised if they were not covered in each paper this week.

Dr. Regier's (Henry) paper as well as mine were in regard to local, long standing environmental problems. Henry's focused somewhat on the bigger picture of the Grand River valley and basin whereas mine was focused on Chemtura and the Canagagigue Creek . I also commented on the ongoing gamesmanship by Chemtura, the Ontario M.O.E. and their fellow travellors on Woolich Council. Mark Bauman did some minor complaining after my Delegation regarding the definition of "favours" which I stated Chemtura had called in from recently re-elected Councillors.

Lisa MacDonald's Delegation was extremely interesting and as I indicated earlier focused on returning Councillor Murray Martin. While clearly not of the Pamela Wallin/Mike Duffy category nevertheless I await further developments. I would further suggest that Councillor Martin's alleged impropriety's are not of the Todd Cowan variety either. I'm trying to be careful here because truth be told while I think I understand the allegations I personally have not seen the evidence nor necessarily would I immediately understand it if it was available to me.

There should also be an excellent letter To The Editor in this week's Elmira Independent. I have read it and found it to be extraordinarily clear and accurate and should set a few things straight. Woolwich Council and Mayor Shantz, it's time to give your heads a serious shake.